Reviews
Part of Before-and-after workshop makeovers leave things out of the photo
5 things about home workshop makeovers worth your time
Home workshop makeovers comparison: assess the base, set bench height, plan a temporary surface, protect the top, and choose plywood over glass.
What to take away
- Most benches worth keeping need a new top, not a new bench. The base is usually the part that has aged well.
- Decide the height before anything else, because it has to agree with your new machine tables.
- You need a temporary surface during the makeover. Plan it, or the new bench becomes the site table.
- Glass work surfaces are a poor choice in a shop, and there is a documented reason beyond the obvious.
A makeover is the natural moment to fix the bench, and also the moment when a good base gets thrown out with a tired top. The bench looks worst when the room around it looks best, which is exactly when the decision gets made emotionally. Judge the base and the top separately, because they usually need different answers.
Replace, resurface or keep
Best answer
- Base rigid, top scarred
- Resurface
- Base racks, top sound
- Rebuild the base, keep the top
- Both tired, height wrong
- Replace
- Everything fine, layout changed
- Keep and add casters
Why
- Base rigid, top scarred
- Rigidity is the expensive part to build
- Base racks, top sound
- Bracing or a new frame is cheap
- Both tired, height wrong
- You are rebuilding it anyway
- Everything fine, layout changed
- Mobility solves layout, not condition
Test the base by pushing hard at working height. Movement in the frame is the deciding factor, not how the top looks.
Replace, resurface or keep?
Base rigid, top scarred -> Resurface
Base racks, top sound -> Rebuild base, keep top
Both tired, height wrong -> Replace
Get the heights to agree
A makeover changes machine positions, so set every work surface to one reference height. For an outfeed surface, measure the saw table height from the floor, subtract the new top thickness and caster height to set the leg length, then check the finished surface with a straightedge spanning both. An outfeed surface that does not agree with the saw table is worse than no outfeed surface at all.
Decide this before you build anything, because it determines leg length, caster height and the thickness of a new top.
Plan the temporary surface
You will need somewhere to work during the makeover, and if you do not plan it, the new bench becomes the paint table on day two. Sawhorses with an old sheet on top are enough. Keep them out of the room being worked on.
Protect any finished surface you intend to keep. A sheet of hardboard screwed down through the sacrificial layer costs almost nothing and prevents the damage that happens between phases. A beginner workshop makeover kit should start with layout and marking tools before any power tool purchase.
Stripping an old top is a chemical job
The federal standard for methylene chloride—OSHA's Methylene Chloride standard at 29 CFR 1910.1052—sets exposure limits, monitoring, respiratory protection and regulated area requirements for workplaces where the solvent is used, and lists the acute and chronic effects driving those controls.
It does not regulate a homeowner refinishing a bench, and it does explain why enclosed spaces are the dangerous case. Read the product label, work outdoors where you can, and treat a closed garage as the wrong place. In many cases planing or sanding a top flat is both quicker and safer than stripping it.
Glass is a poor shop surface
It appears in makeover photographs because it looks clean. Beyond the obvious problem of dropped tools, tempered glass furniture can break unexpectedly. The Consumer Product Safety Commission has published a tempered glass safety alert describing spontaneous breakage in glass furniture and what consumers should watch for.
In a room where things get dropped and clamped, choose a material that fails predictably instead. Plywood is a practical alternative for a general-purpose bench top.
Our makeover overview covers the project as a whole, and our guide to correcting work surface errors covers checking the result.
